Hide menu

Legal aspects of functional sales under scrutiny


A research group led by Jan Kellgren of the Division for Commercial and Business Law is to examine the legal aspects of functional sales in the field of illumination. New business models are appearing in which companies offer functionality, rather than services or products.

The use of functional sales is one of several methods expected to increase the efficiency with which we use society’s resources. By selling a service rather than a product – cooling instead of refrigerators, transport instead of lorries, illumination instead of light fittings or lamps – the purchaser obtains better control of costs, while the seller obtains increased influence over the service and maintenance of the products. In this way, the seller can have greater influence of the lifetime of the products and have full control over when parts need to be exchanged or undergo service. Examples of functions that many companies already purchase are access to photocopies, green plants and coffee/tea.

New major international markets are appearing in which Swedish manufacturing industry can gain competitive advantages by offering environmentally sustainable and economically competitive services and functions.

However, if new business models are to be developed and applied, the legal conditions must be both unambiguous and fit for purpose. A research group at LiU, under the leadership of Associate Professor Jan Kellgren of the Division for Commercial and Business Law, is now to provide answers to several legal questions raised by new business models. In particular, the research project will look at the functional sale of illumination, having received funding of SEK 4.5 million from the Swedish Energy Agency.

Jan Kellgren“We will be examining illumination, but the project will generate generally applicable knowledge concerning the legal aspects of functional sales: civil law, tax law and accounting law,” says Jan Kellgren.

Questions that need to be answered include what the seller should receive if the customer does not pay on time for illumination of a certain intensity in a number of rooms, and what will happen when the house is sold.

Another aspect that seller does not have full control over is how the products are used, and this raises the question of whether the products, such as large light fittings and other equipment, must be entered as an expense immediately, even though they will generate income for several years. Does the seller have the right, for example, to include the equipment as an asset in the balance sheet?

Other questions are where the boundary goes between long-term leasing and purchase, how much VAT is to be paid/reclaimed, and the timing of VAT transactions. When does the sale actually occur, and what is it that is sold?

“The legal status of functional sales is fundamental if the business model is to work. If companies are to have the confidence required to make new investments or change existing ones, unambiguous regulations are required,” says Jan Kellgren.

The research group for the project “Sale of illumination – legal aspects of function-based business models” consists of, in addition to Jan Kellgren, Herbert Jacobsson, senior lecturer in commercial law; Ingrid Arnesdotter, professor emerita in commercial law, and Professor Mattias Lindahl, of the Division of Environmental Technology and Management. For this reason, the results will be included in research into new business models for the more efficient use of resources, carried out within the research programme Mistra REES (Resource Efficient and Effective Solutions).

The project will continue throughout 2017 and 2018.

Timing is everything

Jan Kellgren and Docent Stefan Schiller, of the Division of Business Administration, have recently been awarded a research grant from the Torsten Söderberg Foundation to study the accounting and tax consequences of events that occur between the end of the financial year (or another significant date) and the submission of the annual report or tax returns. A number questions relating to tax law are not clear under existing regulations.

“Whose perspective is the most accurate? What should the company have investigated or known when the annual report was written,” asks Jan Kellgren, without being able to give an answer.

Some examples: A customer goes bankrupt a few weeks after the accounting date and the accounts receivable become worthless. How should the company management decide the value of the accounts receivable on the accounting date?

A company invests money in a sports team and intends to benefit from the goodwill, and thus views the investment as tax deductible. When the annual report has been completed, but before it has been approved and submitted, it turns out that the team’s star was using illegal drugs at the time the investment was made. Is it even so justified to deduct the sponsoring expenses as a business expense? When the decision to sponsor the team was made, it appeared to be a good decision. Is the true situation to be what determines tax liability, or what the situation appeared to be?

“We plan to travel to the Nordic countries and investigate how these issues are handled there. There may be interesting solutions that we can use as inspiration in Sweden,” says Jan Kellgren.

This research is based on, among other things, work that Jan Kellgren published in his book (in Swedish) “Tidsfrågor i skatterättstillämpningen”, details of which are available at the link below.

Photo of illumination: iStock Photo


Tidsfrågor i skatterättstillämpningen, Jan Kellgren, Jure 2016
Division for Commercial and Business Law
Mistra REES (external link)


Monica Westman Svenselius Mon Jan 16 14:57:38 CET 2017

Prehistoric seeds

Hidden seeds reveal Canary Islands history

Have you tried the national dish gofio while on holiday on the Canary Islands? If so, you have eaten the same food as the original inhabitants ate, nearly 2,000 years ago.

David Bastviken

Prestigious grant to environmental research

David Bastviken, professor at Environmental Change, part of LiU’s Department of Thematic Studies, has received EUR 2 million through an ERC Consolidator Grant, a funding type that supports excellent research.

Björn-Ola Linnér

Geopolitics and sustainable development

LiU professor Björn-Ola Linnér has been appointed head of a new major research programme in geopolitics and sustainable development.

Markus Heilig

Childhood trauma increases dependency risk

Markus Heilig, professor at the Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, has been awarded SEK 300,000 from Systembolaget (the Swedish state alcohol monopoly) for research into the relationship between childhood trauma and an increased risk of alcohol-related problems.

LiU students studying Swedish

Conference on refugee reception

For three days in January, Linköping University and partners are hosting a conference aimed at highlighting good examples and finding innovative solutions to how municipalities can receive refugees.


Two LiU researchers each receive SEK 12 million

Two young LiU researchers, Daniel Aili and Björn Alling, have each been awarded SEK 12 million by the Swedish Foundation for Strategic Research, SSF. A total of 20 researchers have been selected within the Future Research Leaders programme.

Sign with the university name: Universidad Eduardo Mondlane

New maths collaboration in Mozambique

With a grant from Sida, the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency, Linköping University’s Department of Mathematics can commence an educational project in a fourth African country, Mozambique, together with the Universidade Eduardo Mondlane (UEM).

The Big Bell Test

109,000 Bell test participants

Can atoms talk to each other? This is the question posed by Swedish radio programme “Vetandets värld”, after the BIG Bell test collected no less than 95 million ones and zeros from more than 109,000 participants, 3,283 of them in Sweden.

Nils Johansson

Political obstacles to mineral recycling

We are keen to discuss how to restructure to bring about a sustainable society, but we seldom discuss how we manage resources. Nils Johansson shows in his doctoral thesis that current policies lead to an increased waste of mineral resources, not the reverse.

Pia Rundgren

New director of human resources at LiU

Pia Rundgren has been appointed as new director of human resources at Linköping University.


New master’s programme in design

The admission period for LiU’s new international master’s programme in design is now underway. This two-year interdisciplinary design programme addresses societal challenges, with the first year focussed on food waste and nomadic welfare.

Johan D Söderholm

The Wallenberg Centre – research at the medicine-technology interface

The new Wallenberg Centre for Molecular Medicine at Linköping University was officially opened on 8 December. The centre is one component of a major initiative in Swedish research in the field of life sciences. The opening was marked by a two-day scientific symposium.

AHA Award 2016

American award to LiU professor

Tiny Jaarsma, professor in caring sciences at the Department of Social and Welfare Studies has received a Distinguished Scientist Award from the American Heart association, AHA.

Housam Al-Mosilli

Linköping’s writer in refuge

The Syrian writer Housam Al-Mosilli recently spoke at Linköping University’s Valla Library about life in Syria, the escape that brought him to Linköping and freedom of expression.

Christmas caps

Christmas concerts, carols and choirs

Christmas without concerts? That’s simply not an option for LiU’s choirs. This year, seven ensembles will perform at not less than 18 concerts.

cyclist in the inner city

Smart cities – more talk than action

The concept of “smart cities” is being used increasingly often within urban development. But this concept lacks a clear definition, and the way it is used depends on who is using it. These results are presented in a thesis by Malin Granath.

Old tourists in Spain

Cloudy skies on the Costa del Sol

Homelessness, ill health and the fear of dying in a foreign country. These are elements in some of the narratives collected by researcher Anna Gavanas in her book about Swedish pensioners who have emigrated to Spain.

Lena Sommestad

Lena Sommestad new chair of LiU Board

The Swedish government has appointed Lena Sommestad as new chair of the university board at LiU. Lena Sommestad has previously been minister for the environment and is today the county governor of Halland.

Daniel Aili and Sasan Zandi

Two new Wallenberg Fellows at LiU

LiU has two new Wallenberg Academy Fellows, who will get the opportunity to develop their research ideas. The challenges they’re taking on relate to relapses in acute leukemia, a form of cancer, and materials that can help us create new organs using 3D printers.

Helene Hellmark Knutsson

SEK 3 billion extra to research

Benefit to society, increased gender equality and initiatives linked to societal challenges are in focus in the research bill presented by the Swedish government. The bill provides extra money to LiU for research into 5G and digitalisation.

Electronic paper

SEK 20 million to energy research

Five researchers at LiU have each been awarded SEK 1 million per year for four years in research grants from a joint initiative by the Swedish Energy Agency and the Swedish Research Council in energy-oriented basic research.

Human petting a chicken

Measuring stress in chicken’s blood

How are animals in food production affected by stressful experiences early in life? Per Jensen wants to find out whether it is possible to see the traces of stress much later. He has been awarded SEK 8 million by Formas, the Swedish research council for sustainable development, to study the stress reactions of chickens in detail.

Timber truck not carrying a load

Large research grant for greener timber trucks

With the aid of a supercomputer, a wind tunnel and a research grant of SEK 5.7 million, the 2,000 timber trucks in Sweden are to achieve lower fuel consumption, becoming in this way a little bit greener.

cecilia åsberg

SEK 4 million to environmental humanities

The Seed Box, Sweden’s largest research programme in the environmental humanities, is now allocating grants to researchers, writers and artists around the world.

Rat bones in a jar

Sooner on your feet after hip fracture

An already available drug can help patients get back on their feet more rapidly after a hip fracture, according to an international study published in the Journal of Bone Joint Surgery. The results suggest that treatment with the drug accelerates the healing process in broken bones.

Illustration of antibody

Major grants for biosensor research

Biosensors with extremely small gold particles known as “nanoparticles” are helping researchers to improve the development of biological drugs. They are also playing a role in the diagnosis of disease. Daniel Aili at LiU is the principal investigator for a project that has been awarded SEK 5 million from the Swedish Research Council and Vinnova’s joint initiative in biological drugs.


when researchers meet vulnerability

Child in SyriaMalin Thor Tureby was keynote speaker at an international conference on oral history.


global media hit

CatCats that meow with a dialect have caused a sensation in the world media. Robert Eklund, a linguist who works with cats at the Department of Culture and Communication, has lost count of the number of times the work has been reported in the media.


farewell exchange students

Farewell Mingle 2016On 6 December, a Farewell Mingle was held for departing exchange students who have studied at Linköping University.


success for new master's

Stefan Jonsson"We have a global and critical perspective that attracts today's students," says Stefan Jonsson, professor at REMESO, about the Faculty of Arts and Science’s first international master’s programme at REMESO in Norrköping - Ethnic and Migration Studies.


health is our new religion

YogisAchieving perfect health has become a religion in the western world, according to a newly published study. Barbro Wijma, professor emerita and physician with many years of experience meeting patients, views this development with dismay.


black in sweden

Victoria Kawesa

Skin colour matters, also in Sweden. But many people don’t accept that racism is a problem here – only in other countries. So claims doctoral student Victoria Kawesa, who writes about black feminism and whiteness in Sweden.


redress for neglect

Shadows of peopleJohanna Sköld from Child Studies at Linköping University co-organised an international workshop where researchers compared various models of compensation for institutional neglect and abuse.


tomorrow's nobel laureates?

Pupils from a primary school in Skäggetorp Anna Lindström and Monika Lopez of the Department of Culture and Communication applied earlier this year for funding for an initiative in an issue relating to refugees. The funding was granted, and the “Tomorrow’s Nobel laureates” project was born. 


Alumni of the year 1

Suad Ali, porträtt

Suad Ali, expert on Sweden’s refugee quota, works tirelessly for refugees worldwide. For her dedication she has been chosen as one of Linköping University’s two Alumni of the Year.


Alumni of the Year 2

Thomas-Lunner-i-studioThomas Lunner’s research has given improved hearing to millions of people with impaired hearing. He has been chosen as one of this year’s Alumni of the Year.



Discussed mathematics

Jonas Bergman Ärlebäck vid tavlan i klassrummet på Skäggetorpsskolan. Foto från skolans fb.What’s zero to the power of zero? Jonas Bergman Ärlebäck, senior lecturer at LiU’s Department of Mathematics, rushed over to a local primary school to discuss mathematics. 


conference on climate change denial

Picture of globeMartin Hultman, who works with environmental history and the history of ideas, is organising the world’s first conference on climate change denial.


lessons for life in guatemala

Sabina Nordén and Sofie Folkesson building a school in Guatemala.Engineering students Sabina Nordén and Sofie Folkesson took a year off university to renovate a school in Guatemala – using PET bottles.

 All features

Follow us

Nyhetsbrev LiU-news


RSS RSS Events


In brief


LiU alumnus in Venture Cup’s Top 20

LiU alumnus Bengt Wiberg (who studied economics 1978-81) was unwilling to stop using snus, despite the problems it was causing him. So he invented a new method to package snus, Sting Free snus. Patents have now been sought in 38 countries and the method has been selected as one of Venture Cup’s Top 20 Ideas 2016.

Three days of Julia Kristeva

The famous psychoanalyst, linguist, philosopher and feminist Julia Kristeva has her own dedicated conference. This year it will be held in Stockholm from 13 to 15 October, with researchers from a number of countries coming together to discuss her work and ideas. Co-organisers include LiU’s Department of Culture and Communication.

International conference on aging and the elderly

The global population is becoming increasingly older, while the experiences of the elderly are becoming increasingly diverse. This will be discussed at an international conference on aging to be held in Norrköping, 6-7 October 2016.

Malmstens at London Design Fair

Graduates of the Furniture Design Programme at Carl Malmsten Furniture Studies will attend the London Design Fair, 22-25 September. The graduates will show innovative lighting for the private and public sectors. The pieces were first presented at this year’s Stockholm Furniture & Light Fair. In conjunction with the Stockholm fair, the graduates received invitations to participate in London.

Conference on education and gender

Researchers from around the world will gather in Linköping from 15 to 17 June to discuss gender, nationalism and intersectionality, with a focus on schools and education.
“We want to shed particular light on Sweden and Scandinavia. We believe we have so much equality, and this belief is part of our identity. But it can also lead to superiority over people from other countries. That ‘we’ are so good and ‘they’ don’t know what we’re talking about,” says Katarina Eriksson Barajas, professor of education at Linköping University.

Page manager: anna.nilsen@liu.se
Last updated: Mon Jan 02 14:13:51 CET 2017